Humor in Music

by Susan M

This topic was already covered to some extent in the Novelty Songs thread. I like novelty songs, but they can wear thin after awhile. I know people who don’t like humor in music at all, though, and I could never really understand that. What I love most are the bands and songs that can combine both seriousness and humor together.

Barenaked Ladies - Grade 9

Ben Folds Five - Steven’s Last Night in Town
Two great examples are Barenaked Ladies and Ben Folds. They’re both funny enough that I’ll occasionally laugh out loud at one of their songs. But have enough serious material that their songs don’t get old. I think my favorite line in this Ben Folds song is when he says, "I think Steven was mad, maybe he wasn’t mad, but we felt very strange in the moment, but the moment was passed and forgotten about." But my favorite line to sing is, "Lost points with the ladies for saying he couldn’t love a woman with cellulite."

Young Fresh Fellows - Amy Grant
When I was a teen in Seattle there was one local band that was my favorite to see live because they were so funny, the Young Fresh Fellows. Most people don’t know this, but in addition to the grunge scene going on in those days, Seattle had a whole other scene of funny pop bands. I think the only one to really gain any sort of popularity was the Posies. But it was the Fellows who ruled the school. "What the people want to hear is pure, unadulterated schlock."

Built to Spill - I Would Hurt a Fly
Built to Spill are a band I consider really funny…but I don’t know if anyone else will agree with me. I know the vocals can be a bit whiny and may bother some, but his lyrics just crack me up. "There’s a mean bone in my body."

Flaming Lips - Everything’s Exploding
There’s probably funnier songs I could post by them, later stuff, but all I have is one of their early albums. And it’s one of my all-time favorite albums. "When I look in my mirror and my brains are falling out of my head, well there’s nothing wrong, it’s just the way I feel. If you don’t like it, write your own song."

The Decemberists - Los Angeles, I’m Yours
LA is just too easy to make fun of. "I can see your undies."

Madness - Baggy Trousers
Madness started out as a British ska band in the 80’s, but they later just became more pop than ska. They’re known in the US for their hit "Our House." They actually have a large catalogue of great stuff. They can do funny, novelty type stuff, and serious melancholy stuff.

Toy Dolls - Fiery Jack
Can’t do a post on humorous music and not include something punk. The Toy Dolls were a British punk band with really goofy songs. I debated between posting this or something by the Buzzcocks, and figured I’d go with these guys since I’m guessing people are already familiar with the Buzzcocks. Even though the Toy Dolls border on novelty.

Hoodoo Gurus - Death Defying
The Hoodoo Guru’s first two albums are pure genius. They’re the kings of funny storytelling in songs. Well, maybe the Barenaked Ladies have them beat. But the Hoodoo Gurus are a personal fave from my teenage years. I wanted to use my favorite song of theirs, called “Dig It Up,” all about how you shouldn’t give up on love. The narrator is so prepared to not give up on love that he’s going to dig up his dead girlfriend, in fact. But I don’t have it in digital format. So I’m using “Death Defying,” which cracks me up simply because of the “ooh wee’s” in it. I’ve heard this song was written because the band had lost a lot of friends to the AIDS virus.

All songs should be posted in the radio.blog, let me know if any give you problems.

9 Comments

  1. The new Decemberists’ album “Picaresque” came out this week. There’s some good natured fun in the album - songs about male prostitutes, mariners taking revenge on one another, etc. The liner notes have some playful photographs of the characters that inhabit the songs too.

    So where does one draw the line between humor and novelty?

    Comment by Dallin I — March 25, 2005 @ 3:48 pm

  2. Well for me, I think it comes down to whether the band only does humorous stuff. And now that I think about it, the Toy Dolls (AFAIK) don’t, so by that definition they’d be a novelty act. But there’s a whole humorous punk thing that I don’t really deem novelty, like the Dead Milkmen, and that’s how I’ve always thought of the Dolls.

    Comment by Susan Malmrose — March 25, 2005 @ 6:30 pm

  3. I think certain songs by Morrissey and the Smiths would also qualify as they are definitely not novelty songs, but can be very witty.
    Usually, it’s just one clever line in the middle of an otherwise serious song.

    Comment by NFlanders — March 28, 2005 @ 10:36 am

  4. Okay, music experts. There’s an audio clip at the beginning of “Everything’s Explodin’” by THE FLAMING LIPS. A man says, “Take this brother may it serve you well.”

    I knew I’d heard that before, so I wracked my brains for the last few days and finally remembered it’s in “Revolution #9″ by THE BEATLES. But what I want to know is where does that clip come from originally before The Beatles threw it into that song. Anyone?

    Comment by Brian G — March 29, 2005 @ 6:06 pm

  5. Brian: no one knows. Some theorize that it’s more proof of Paul’s death.

    number 9….number 9…..number 9…..number 9…..number 9…..

    Comment by Steve Evans — March 29, 2005 @ 6:27 pm

  6. How exactly does TMBG not even get a mention in this post?

    Comment by John C. — April 3, 2005 @ 7:40 pm

  7. I’m not sure why I left them out, but I’m pretty sure I had a reason at the time. They’re one of my faves too though.

    Comment by Susan Malmrose — April 3, 2005 @ 8:01 pm

  8. i think that this is interesting. i am writing a paper for college on the use of humor in music, one of my prime examples was the Barenaked ladies, i was a fan until i noticed that their lyrics were not very humorous but instead sarcastic. After listening to them for periods of time i found myself getting really annoyed and it has gotten to the point where if the Barenaked ladies come on the radio i turn the staion because i dont want their “humor” sprung on me. i have to be ready for it.
    -Brad

    Comment by Brad Felts — November 1, 2005 @ 6:15 pm

  9. Brad, I wrote another post here about sarcasm in song, and I talk specifically about Barenaked Ladies. Or at least, one of their songs.

    Comment by Susan M — November 1, 2005 @ 6:31 pm